I take your point, Ed; I just found a quote of from one of your answers of Aug 3rd:
and just to labour the point to exonerate myself for my original answer, I can feel my new tensioner & idler wheels are made of neo-rubber, but my old ones feel like bloody metal! And, as I stated earlier, I can break bits off with pliers very easily. They're shagged, I reckon.....To inspect the tensioner you need to remove the 4 bolts and pull it out. You want to see a nice round neoprene wheel rather than one which looks like a sprocket with chunks out of it. Don't worry if it's hard (old rumor) because when new they are hard.